How Accurate Is The Mel Meter Paranormal Multimeter?
The Mel Meter is a paranormal multi-tool designed by Gary Galka, a name that may be familiar to some as Gary occasionally appears on the long-running US ghost hunting show, 'Ghost Adventures'. He invents paranormal investigation tools for Zak Bagans and the rest of the show's team.
The device is named after Gary's late daughter, the word Mel is short for Melissa. There are a few different versions of the Mel Meter, but they all have an EMF meter and a sensitive ambient air temperature measurement built in. These are the device's core functions and are switched on by holding down the 'power' button.
The exact model we are testing is the MEL-8704R-REM-ATDD. As the model number suggests, it also has REM-Pod and ATDD functionality built in. The inclusion of these two additional features make the Mel Meter great value for money, as it costs around the same as a stand alone REM-Pod.
To get a feel for how reliable a Mel Meter is on an investigation, we put it through its paces in a controlled environment.
The Mel Meter's main feature is the EMF meter. When powered on the current electromagnetic field strength is displayed on the screen in milligauss (mG).
I tested the Mel Meter by putting it next to a microwave oven and comparing it with other devices that can detect EMF, including the popular K-II meter and an EDI+ meter.
When placed in front of the microwave, the Mel Meter gave a reading of 30.5mG. The two K-II meters maxed out and said the microwave was kicking out more than 20mG (this is their limit), while the EDI+ gave a reading of 11.9mG.
So, three of the four devices thought the strength of the field was at least 20mG, including the Mel Meter which gave the highest reading. I think this reading is fairly accurate. The EDI+ was way lower than the other three devices so it should be discredited, while the K-IIs both maxed out and failed to show the true reading.
The Mel Meters does have a wider range of sensitivity, which could account for the higher reading. Its makers claim it can detect electromagnetic frequencies as low as 20Hz, where as 50Hz is a K-II's lower limit. It's hard to know exactly how accurate the Mel Meter is, but it is at least very responsive, and let's be honest - most casual ghost hunters don't really care what the actual strength of the field is in milligauss.
Advertisement ‐ Content Continues Below.
I tried to affect the Mel Meter's EMF reading using various transmitting devices, I found that a mobile phone failed to trigger the device even when it was making a call. This means that the Mel Meter isn't as susceptible to radio interference in the same way a K-II meter is. My walkie talkie also didn't trigger the EMF sensor when used in proximity of the device.
However, I was able to get the EMF meter to register a change when I used a wireless microphone near it, the kind used by television film crews. Although the transmitter had to be very close to the Mel Meter in order to get a reaction and at this distance it would be clearly visible what was causing it to trigger.
The biggest upgrade to the new model of the Mel Meter is the inclusion of a REM-Pod. These are usually stand-alone devices that emit a static electric field from an antenna. If something enters that field then the device can detect its proximity and alert the user to it using a series of five lights on the top of the device and an audible tone.
The Mel Meter's REM feature can be switched on using a push button underneath the flip-out stand on the back of the device. When activated the first light on a bar of six at the top of the device lights green - the other five light up different colours to indicate proximity. It should be noted that the REM can work independently from the rest of the device. You can keep the device turned off if you wish and just use the REM function.
I compared the Mel Meter side-by-side with a REM-Pod and the two behaved almost exactly the same, both were as sensitive to objects passing into their field. Having used both a REM-Pod and Mel Meter a fair amount, I have to say they are quite robust and hard to get to trigger incorrectly.
The device's instructions state that the REM can be triggered by fluorescent lights and high power handheld communication devices, such as walkie talkies. I tested this using a mobile phone in various states, including while making a call, the device didn't trigger at all, however a walkie talkie in close proximity did make the device trigger.
One important thing to remember with the REM-Pod is that when something passes into its field and triggers it, but stays inside the field, after seven seconds the device will reset and the tone will cease. However if that same object moves out of the field, this will also affect the field and result in the device triggering.
There is a button on the side of the device, 'REM zero', which will manually reset the device should it persistently alert when something enters its field. There's also a range button, pressing it will adjust the REM-Pod's sensitivity through five different levels which are indicated on the lights at the top of the front panel.
The REM-Pod is best used when the device is placed on a flat surface, the flip-out stand makes it perfect for this function. If the device triggers after placing it on a surface, simply use the 'REM zero' button to reset it. The Mel Meter can be used as a handheld device, but it's recommended to keep your hand low on the device to avoid interfering with the REM function. Again you can 'zero' the device after taking hold of it to reset it.
The Mel Meter has a built in temperature sensor, unlike other similar devices the temperature probe plugs into the top of the device. Having an external probe makes the device's temperature reading far more accurate than any similar devices. After taking it out of a kit bag and turning it on, the temperature reading stabilises and reasonably accurately displays the ambient temperature in the room after just a few seconds. The temperature reading can be switched between centigrade and fahrenheit.
The Mel Meter is also really responsive to temperature changes. When I tested the EDI+ Meter, after 20 minutes in a fridge, the EDI+ only dropped from around 22°C to 19.4°C, however the Mel Meter with its external probe took just two minutes to drop to 6.7°C - a pretty accurate reflection of the temperature of the inside of a fridge that's just been opened.
Another new feature in this model of Mel Meter is the Ambient Temperature Deviation Detection (ATDD) circuit. Like the REM-Pod, this is turned on from the back of the device and can be used without the main device being powered on. However, the ATDD will not work unless the REM-Pod is also switched on.
The ATDD function will alert you to sudden changes in temperature of +/- five degree via an audible tone and a light on the side of the device. The pitch of the tone indicates the change, a higher pitch for a temperature rise and a lower pitch for a drop. The light helps distinguish between the two tones, with a blue light for a downward drop or red for a rise.
Near the light on the side, there's also the 'ATDD zero' button, which can be pressed to reset the device should you need to after moving the device into a room or area with a different temperature. Just like the main temperature sensor on the device, the ATDD feature is also very responsive, accurate and useful.
Of all the paranormal devices I have tested, the Mel Meter is probably the most accurate EMF meter and thermometer I've seen. Both features give pretty stable and realistic readings, this is also true of the ADTT feature which can alert you to changes in the ambient air temperature.
The REM-Pod feature is also well worth having. It's not prone to false positives and often won't trigger on an investigation, which I think is a good thing, because it is very responsive to something moving within its field.
Reviews Of Similar Gadgets View All
What Makes An EMF Detector Go Off?
September 14, 2020
How To Use A TriField Meter On A Ghost Hunt
September 06, 2020
How Accurate Is The EDI+ Paranormal Multimeter?
February 01, 2020
K-II EMF Meters: Can They Really Detect Ghosts?
January 25, 2020
What Is The Best Ghost Hunting Gadget?
January 20, 2020
How The Electromagnetic Spectrum Relates To The Paranormal
November 24, 2019
Why Do Ghost Hunters Use EMF Meters?
June 13, 2018
GhostArk: The All-in-One Ghost Hunting Device
January 21, 2016
60 Paranormal Terms Every Ghost Hunter Should Know
December 13, 2021
Spirit Boxes & The Ghosts That Communicate Through Radio Transmissions
December 11, 2021
The Problem With Calling Out On A Ghost Hunt
November 25, 2021
Ghost Code App Test: Does It Really Evoke Paranormal Activity?
November 20, 2021
The Problem With Full Spectrum Cameras
November 17, 2021
Using Spectrograms To Analyse EVP Recordings
November 13, 2021
How Many Ouija Boards Have Been Sold Ever?
November 12, 2021
EVP Quiz: Test Your Electronic Voice Phenomenon Knowledge
November 06, 2021
Creator Of A New Phone App Claims It Can Trigger Paranormal Activity
November 02, 2021
Is It Morally Wrong To Hunt Ghosts At Concentration Camps?
October 13, 2021
You May Also Like